Logo image
From materials to meaning: exploring the impact of cognitive scaffolding on group dynamics and sensemaking
Dissertation   Open access

From materials to meaning: exploring the impact of cognitive scaffolding on group dynamics and sensemaking

Andrew James Kreps
University of Iowa
Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), University of Iowa
Summer 2025
DOI: 10.17077/etd.006755
pdf
AndrewK_Dissertation2.93 MBDownloadView
Open Access Free to read and download

Abstract

Supporting student learning in chemistry requires designing instructional environments that promote deep engagement, scaffold complex thinking, and create equitable opportunities for students to construct understanding, among many other factors. One strategy for supporting student learning is with cognitive scaffolding, which is the intentional sequencing of questions based on levels of cognitive processing, which can provide embedded support and reduce cognitive load during problem solving. This dissertation examines how cognitively scaffolded activities influence collaborative learning, particularly in guided-inquiry settings where students work together to make sense of chemical concepts. Chapter Two evaluates classroom materials developed by faculty who participated in the Promoting Active Learning in Analytical Chemistry (PALAC) professional development workshop. The study analyzed 134 in-class activities and found that while many activities included higher-order questions, consistent cognitive scaffolding across questions was limited. These findings underscore the importance of professional development, which emphasizes the creation, structuring, and facilitation of cognitively supportive materials. Chapter Three investigates the impact of cognitively scaffolded activities on student engagement in a second-semester general chemistry course. Using the ICAP framework, which describes four levels of cognitive engagement, this study compares group discourse from two cohorts, one using original materials and the other using cognitively scaffolded versions. Results suggest that our cognitive scaffolding promotes sustained cognitive engagement and supports the use of reasoning during higher-order tasks, though shifts in social dynamics were less pronounced. Chapter Four deepens this analysis by examining how cognitive scaffolding interacts with group dynamics and students’ approaches to sensemaking. Drawing on the sensemaking framework, this study analyzes the discourse of two student groups working on scaffolded activities. The findings indicate that while our cognitive scaffolding supports students' cognitive processes and the use of reasoning, equitable discourse and effective facilitation are critical for shaping students' stances toward collaborative science learning. Collectively, this research demonstrates how Marzano’s taxonomy can serve as both a diagnostic and developmental tool for cognitive scaffolding and how that scaffolding can help sustain engagement and promote the use of reasoning in group learning environments, but its effectiveness is mediated by facilitation practices and group dynamics. The work provides evidence-based recommendations for instructional design and facilitation that support the development of equitable and cognitively rich group learning experiences in chemistry education.
Active learning Discussion activities Group work Marzano taxonomy Scaffolding

Details

Metrics

8 File views/ downloads
57 Record Views
Logo image