Dissertation
(Un)supportive messages during a time of transition: younger women’s memories of support during the re-entry phase of breast cancer survivorship
University of Iowa
Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), University of Iowa
Autumn 2020
DOI: 10.17077/etd.005715
Abstract
Breast cancer is the most common cancer in women, and the greatest cause of death for women 50 years of age and younger in the United States. Compared to older breast cancer survivors, younger survivors (aged 50 and below) experience increased distress, depression, fear of cancer recurrence, physical and psychological symptoms, concerns about managing everyday life, and a lower quality of life. More specifically, women within 18 months of finishing treatment (known as the “re-entry” period) can experience increased feelings of fear, stress, heightened physical and psychological symptoms, and an unfamiliar and altered body. This research considered socially supportive messages, messages spoken with the purpose of helping others to manage distress, as one method to help with younger breast cancer survivors’ coping during re-entry. Little is known about the characteristics of supportive messages that make them more or less supportive regarding breast cancer survivors’ coping during the re-entry period. Using interviews, the purpose of the current research was to describe and better understand the supportiveness and qualities of supportive messages in response to stressors reported by breast cancer survivors in re-entry (N=20) between 25 and 50 years of age. Younger breast cancer survivors noted that helpful supportive messages were those that ultimately acknowledged and validated ongoing challenges and provided comfort to cope with these existing difficulties. Helpful support came in various forms, including the provision of support by other breast cancer survivors, perceptions of available or anticipated network support, unsolicited emotional and tangible support, and validating, or person-centered, emotional support. Unsupportive messages within women’s re-entry experiences included support that dismissed, avoided, or misunderstood the survivor’s lived experience. Unsupportive messages included those that displayed incorrect assumptions of the survivor’s experience, pity and discomfort, discouraging informational support, cultivation or affirmation of negative body image, and unaddressed or dismissed medical concerns. Participants noted potential ways in which socially supportive messages might provide increased comfort and coping during this transitional time. Broadly, women explained the value of supportive messages that acknowledged and validated their challenges and experiences, even when others did not fully understand these difficulties. Survivors explained that their cancer experience was not yet finished, citing numerous emotional and physical difficulties in re-entry that inhibited their adjustment. Participants thus recommended that others provide unsolicited emotional and tangible support in re-entry, as these supportive interactions reminded participants that their challenges were acknowledged and that others were thinking of them. Participants recommended that medical providers proactively elicit health concerns from survivors and endeavor to provide relevant information regarding potential symptoms, side-effects and helpful resources to remedy them. Survivors ultimately desired increased informational support from medical providers, citing that this information would greatly improve both physical and emotional adjustment to life in re-entry. The current research provides insight into the challenging time of transition that characterizes the re-entry period of younger breast cancer survivorship, illuminating that survivorship is not an end but rather a point within the cancer continuum.
Details
- Title: Subtitle
- (Un)supportive messages during a time of transition: younger women’s memories of support during the re-entry phase of breast cancer survivorship
- Creators
- Ariana F. Shahnazi
- Contributors
- Michelle Campo (Advisor)Lindsey Thomas (Committee Member)Mary Charlton (Committee Member)Rachel McLaren (Committee Member)Stephanie Gilbertson-White (Committee Member)
- Resource Type
- Dissertation
- Degree Awarded
- Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), University of Iowa
- Degree in
- Communication Studies
- Date degree season
- Autumn 2020
- DOI
- 10.17077/etd.005715
- Publisher
- University of Iowa
- Number of pages
- viii, 112 pages
- Copyright
- Copyright 2020 Ariana F. Shahnazi
- Language
- English
- Description bibliographic
- Includes bibliographical references (page 84-103).
- Public Abstract (ETD)
Breast cancer is the most common cancer in women, and the greatest cause of death for women 50 years of age and younger in the United States. Compared to older breast cancer survivors, younger survivors (aged 50 and below) experience increased distress, depression, fear of cancer recurrence, physical and psychological symptoms, concerns about managing everyday life, and a lower quality of life. More specifically, women within 18 months of finishing treatment (known as the “re-entry” period) can experience increased feelings of fear, stress, heightened physical and psychological symptoms, and an unfamiliar and altered body. This research considered socially supportive messages, messages spoken with the purpose of helping others to manage distress, as one method to help with younger breast cancer survivors’ coping during re-entry.
Little is known about the characteristics of supportive messages that make them more or less supportive regarding breast cancer survivors’ coping during the re-entry period. Using interviews, the purpose of the current research was to describe and better understand the supportiveness and qualities of supportive messages in response to stressors reported by breast cancer survivors in re-entry (N=20) between 25 and 50 years of age. Results suggested that supportive messages possessed qualities that validated survivors’ emotional and physical challenges in re-entry, while unsupportive messages were dismissive of and misunderstood these challenges. Younger women’s (un)supportive experiences in the current research provide insight into the challenges of re-entry breast cancer survivorship, rising against popular conceptualizations that the cancer experience is complete when treatment comes to an end.
- Academic Unit
- Communication Studies
- Record Identifier
- 9984035795802771
Metrics
91 File views/ downloads
58 Record Views