Logo image
Back
Causal health impacts of power plant emission controls under modeled and uncertain physical process interference
Journal article   Peer reviewed

Causal health impacts of power plant emission controls under modeled and uncertain physical process interference

Nathan B. Wikle and Corwin M. Zigler
The annals of applied statistics, Vol.18(4), pp.2753-2774
12/01/2024
DOI: 10.1214/24-AOAS1904
PMCID: PMC11619076
PMID: 39640359

View Online

Abstract

Causal inference with spatial environmental data is often challenging due to the presence of interference: outcomes for observational units depend on some combination of local and nonlocal treatment. This is especially relevant when estimating the effect of power plant emissions controls on population health, as pollution exposure is dictated by: (i) the location of point-source emissions as well as (ii) the transport of pollutants across space via dynamic physical-chemical processes. In this work we estimate the effectiveness of air quality interventions at coal-fired power plants in reducing two adverse health outcomes in Texas in 2016: pediatric asthma ED visits and Medicare all-cause mortality. We develop methods for causal inference with interference when the underlying network structure is not known with certainty and instead must be estimated from ancillary data. Notably, uncertainty in the interference structure is propagated to the resulting causal effect estimates. We offer a Bayesian, spatial mechanistic model for the interference mapping, which we combine with a flexible nonparametric outcome model to marginalize estimates of causal effects over uncertainty in the structure of interference. Our analysis finds some evidence that emissions controls at upwind power plants reduce asthma ED visits and all-cause mortality; however, accounting for uncertainty in the interference renders the results largely inconclusive.

Details

Metrics

14 Record Views
Logo image