Logo image
Back
Evaluating Lab-Based Eligibility Criteria by Race/Ethnicity in Clinical Trials of Diffuse Large B-Cell Lymphoma
Journal article   Open access   Peer reviewed

Evaluating Lab-Based Eligibility Criteria by Race/Ethnicity in Clinical Trials of Diffuse Large B-Cell Lymphoma

Arushi Khurana, Raphael Mwangi, Loretta J Nastoupil, Patrick M Reagan, Umar Farooq, Jason T Romancik, Timothy McDonnell, Shaun Riska, Izidore S Lossos, Brad S Kahl, …
Blood advances, Vol.8(16), pp.4414-4422
08/27/2024
DOI: 10.1182/bloodadvances.2024012838
PMCID: PMC11375257
PMID: 38991126
url
https://doi.org/10.1182/bloodadvances.2024012838View
Published (Version of record) Open Access

Abstract

Underrepresentation of racial and ethnic subgroups in cancer clinical trials remains a persistent challenge. Restrictive clinical trial eligibility criteria have been shown to exacerbate this problem. We previously identified that up to 24% of patients treated with standard immunochemotherapy (IC) would have been excluded from recent first-line trials in diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL) based on 5 lab-based criteria. These ineligible patients had worse clinical outcomes and increased deaths related to lymphoma progression suggesting the potential exclusion of patients who could have benefited most from the novel therapies being evaluated. Utilizing data from the prospectively enrolled Lymphoma Epidemiology Outcomes (LEO) Cohort study, with demographics broadly similar to the U.S. patients diagnosed with lymphoma, we evaluated the impact of laboratory eligibility criteria from recent first-line DLBCL trials across various racial and ethnic backgrounds. There were significant differences in the baseline lab values by race/ethnicity with Black/African American (AA) patients having the lowest mean hemoglobin and highest creatinine clearance. Based on recent clinical trial eligibility criteria, AA and Hispanic patients had higher rates of lab-based ineligibility compared to Non-Hispanic Whites. The largest gap in the clinical outcomes between eligible (ref) and non-eligible patients was noted within AA patients with an overall survival hazard ratio based on POLARIX clinical trial criteria of 4.09, 95% CI: 1.83-9.14. A thoughtful approach to the utility of each criterion and cut offs for eligibility needs to be evaluated in the context of its differential impact across various racial/ethnic groups.Underrepresentation of racial and ethnic subgroups in cancer clinical trials remains a persistent challenge. Restrictive clinical trial eligibility criteria have been shown to exacerbate this problem. We previously identified that up to 24% of patients treated with standard immunochemotherapy (IC) would have been excluded from recent first-line trials in diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL) based on 5 lab-based criteria. These ineligible patients had worse clinical outcomes and increased deaths related to lymphoma progression suggesting the potential exclusion of patients who could have benefited most from the novel therapies being evaluated. Utilizing data from the prospectively enrolled Lymphoma Epidemiology Outcomes (LEO) Cohort study, with demographics broadly similar to the U.S. patients diagnosed with lymphoma, we evaluated the impact of laboratory eligibility criteria from recent first-line DLBCL trials across various racial and ethnic backgrounds. There were significant differences in the baseline lab values by race/ethnicity with Black/African American (AA) patients having the lowest mean hemoglobin and highest creatinine clearance. Based on recent clinical trial eligibility criteria, AA and Hispanic patients had higher rates of lab-based ineligibility compared to Non-Hispanic Whites. The largest gap in the clinical outcomes between eligible (ref) and non-eligible patients was noted within AA patients with an overall survival hazard ratio based on POLARIX clinical trial criteria of 4.09, 95% CI: 1.83-9.14. A thoughtful approach to the utility of each criterion and cut offs for eligibility needs to be evaluated in the context of its differential impact across various racial/ethnic groups.

Details

Metrics

3 Record Views
6 Times Cited - Web of Science
Logo image