Journal article
Inter-rater reliability and generalizability of patient note scores using a scoring rubric based on the USMLE Step-2 CS format
Advances in health sciences education : theory and practice, Vol.21(4), pp.761-773
10/01/2016
DOI: 10.1007/s10459-015-9664-3
PMID: 26757931
Abstract
Recent changes to the patient note (PN) format of the United States Medical Licensing Examination have challenged medical schools to improve the instruction and assessment of students taking the Step-2 clinical skills examination. The purpose of this study was to gather validity evidence regarding response process and internal structure, focusing on inter-rater reliability and generalizability, to determine whether a locally-developed PN scoring rubric and scoring guidelines could yield reproducible PN scores. A randomly selected subsample of historical data (post-encounter PN from 55 of 177 medical students) was rescored by six trained faculty raters in November-December 2014. Inter-rater reliability (% exact agreement and kappa) was calculated for five standardized patient cases administered in a local graduation competency examination. Generalizability studies were conducted to examine the overall reliability. Qualitative data were collected through surveys and a rater-debriefing meeting. The overall inter-rater reliability (weighted kappa) was .79 (Documentation = .63, Differential Diagnosis = .90, Justification = .48, and Workup = .54). The majority of score variance was due to case specificity (13 %) and case-task specificity (31 %), indicating differences in student performance by case and by case-task interactions. Variance associated with raters and its interactions were modest (<5 %). Raters felt that justification was the most difficult task to score and that having case and level-specific scoring guidelines during training was most helpful for calibration. The overall inter-rater reliability indicates high level of confidence in the consistency of note scores. Designs for scoring notes may optimize reliability by balancing the number of raters and cases.
Details
- Title: Subtitle
- Inter-rater reliability and generalizability of patient note scores using a scoring rubric based on the USMLE Step-2 CS format
- Creators
- Yoon Soo Park - University of Illinois at ChicagoAbbas Hyderi - University of Illinois at ChicagoGeorges Bordage - University of Illinois at ChicagoKuan Xing - University of Illinois at ChicagoRachel Yudkowsky - University of Illinois at Chicago
- Resource Type
- Journal article
- Publication Details
- Advances in health sciences education : theory and practice, Vol.21(4), pp.761-773
- DOI
- 10.1007/s10459-015-9664-3
- PMID
- 26757931
- ISSN
- 1382-4996
- eISSN
- 1573-1677
- Language
- English
- Date published
- 10/01/2016
- Academic Unit
- Family and Community Medicine; Office of Consultation and Research in Medical Education
- Record Identifier
- 9984658251402771
Metrics
7 Record Views