Journal article
Multiband variability studies and novel broadband SED modeling of Mrk 501 in 2009
Astronomy and astrophysics (Berlin), Vol.603, p.A31
12/30/2016
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/201629540
Abstract
Context. We present an extensive study of the BL Lac object Mrk 501 based on a data set collected during the multi-instrument campaign spanning from 2009 March 15 to 2009 August 1, which includes, among other instruments, MAGIC, VERITAS, Whipple 10 m, and Fermi-LAT to cover the γ-ray range from 0.1 GeV to 20 TeV; RXTE and Swift to cover wavelengths from UV tohard X-rays; and GASP-WEBT, which provides coverage of radio and optical wavelengths. Optical polarization measurements were provided for a fraction of the campaign by the Steward and St. Petersburg observatories. We evaluate the variability of the source and interband correlations, the γ-ray flaring activity occurring in May 2009, and interpret the results within two synchrotron self-Compton (SSC) scenarios. Aims. The multiband variability observed during the full campaign is addressed in terms of the fractional variability, and the possible correlations are studied by calculating the discrete correlation function for each pair of energy bands where the significance was evaluated with dedicated Monte Carlo simulations. The space of SSC model parameters is probed following a dedicated grid-scan strategy, allowing for a wide range of models to be tested and offering a study of the degeneracy of model-to-data agreement in the individual model parameters, hence providing a less biased interpretation than the “single-curve SSC model adjustment” typically reported in the literature. Methods. We find an increase in the fractional variability with energy, while no significant interband correlations of flux changes are found on the basis of the acquired data set. The SSC model grid-scan shows that the flaring activity around May 22 cannot be modeled adequately with a one-zone SSC scenario (using an electron energy distribution with two breaks), while it can be suitably described within a two (independent) zone SSC scenario. Here, one zone is responsible for the quiescent emission from the averaged 4.5-month observing period, while the other one, which is spatially separated from the first, dominates the flaring emission occurring at X-rays and very-high-energy (>100 GeV, VHE) γ rays. The flaring activity from May 1, which coincides with a rotation of the electric vector polarization angle (EVPA), cannot be satisfactorily reproduced by either a one-zone or a two-independent-zone SSC model, yet this is partially affected by the lack of strictly simultaneous observations and the presence of large flux changes on sub-hour timescales (detected at VHE γ rays). Results. The higher variability in the VHE emission and lack of correlation with the X-ray emission indicate that, at least during the 4.5-month observing campaign in 2009, the highest energy (and most variable) electrons that are responsible for the VHE γ rays do not make a dominant contribution to the ~1 keV emission. Alternatively, there could be a very variable component contributing to the VHE γ-ray emission in addition to that coming from the SSC scenario. The studies with our dedicated SSC grid-scan show that there is some degeneracy in both the one-zone and the two-zone SSC scenarios probed, with several combinations of model parameters yielding a similar model-to-data agreement, and some parameters better constrained than others. The observed γ-ray flaring activity, with the EVPA rotation coincident with the first γ-ray flare, resembles those reported previously for low frequency peaked blazars, hence suggesting that there are many similarities in the flaring mechanisms of blazars with different jet properties.
Details
- Title: Subtitle
- Multiband variability studies and novel broadband SED modeling of Mrk 501 in 2009
- Creators
- M. L Ahnen - ETH ZurichS Ansoldi - University of UdineL. A Antonelli - National Institute for AstrophysicsP Antoranz - University of SienaA Babic - University of RijekaB Banerjee - Saha Institute of Nuclear PhysicsP Bangale - Max Planck SocietyU. Barres de Almeida - Max Planck SocietyJ. A Barrio - Universidad Complutense de MadridJ Becerra Gónzalez - Universidad de La LagunaW Bednarek - University of ŁódźE Bernardini - Humboldt-Universität zu BerlinA Berti - University of UdineB Biasuzzi - University of UdineA Biland - ETH ZurichO Blanch - IFAES Bonnefoy - Universidad Complutense de MadridG Bonnoli - National Institute for AstrophysicsF Borracci - Max Planck SocietyT Bretz - École Polytechnique Fédérale de LausanneS Buson - University of PaduaA Carosi - National Institute for AstrophysicsA Chatterjee - Saha Institute of Nuclear PhysicsR Clavero - Universidad de La LagunaP Colin - Max Planck SocietyE Colombo - Universidad de La LagunaJ. L Contreras - Universidad Complutense de MadridJ Cortina - IFAES Covino - National Institute for AstrophysicsP Da Vela - University of SienaF Dazzi - Max Planck SocietyA De Angelis - University of PaduaB De Lotto - University of UdineE de Ona Wilhelmi - Institute for Space SciencesF Di Pierro - National Institute for AstrophysicsM Doert - ETH ZurichA Domínguez - Universidad Complutense de MadridD. Dominis Prester - University of RijekaD Dorner - University of WürzburgM Doro - University of PaduaS Einecke - Technische Universität Dortmund, Dortmund, GermanyD. Eisenacher Glawion - University of WürzburgD Elsaesser - Technische Universität Dortmund, Dortmund, GermanyM Engelkemeier - Technische Universität Dortmund, Dortmund, GermanyV. Fallah Ramazani - University of TurkuA Fernández-Barral - Institut de Fisica d'Altes EnergiesD Fidalgo - Universidad Complutense de MadridM. V Fonseca - Universidad Complutense de MadridL Font - CeresK Frantzen - Technische Universität Dortmund, Dortmund, GermanyC Fruck - Max Planck SocietyD Galindo - Universitat de BarcelonaR. J. García López - Universidad de La LagunaM Garczarczyk - Deutsches Elektronen-SynchrotronD. Garrido Terrats - Universitat Autònoma de BarcelonaM Gaug - CeresP Giammaria - National Institute for AstrophysicsN Godinović - University of RijekaA. González Munoz - IFAED Gora - Deutsches Elektronen-SynchrotronD Guberman - IFAED Hadasch - The University of TokyoA Hahn - Max Planck SocietyY Hanabata - The University of TokyoM Hayashida - The University of TokyoJ Herrera - Universidad de La LagunaJ Hose - Max Planck SocietyD Hrupec - University of RijekaG Hughes - ETH ZurichW Idec - University of ŁódźK Kodani - The University of TokyoY Konno - The University of TokyoH Kubo - The University of TokyoJ Kushida - The University of TokyoA La Barbera - National Institute for AstrophysicsD Lelas - University of RijekaE Lindfors - University of TurkuS Lombardi - National Institute for AstrophysicsF Longo - University of UdineM López - Universidad Complutense de MadridR López-Coto - Institute for High Energy PhysicsP Majumdar - Saha Institute of Nuclear PhysicsM Makariev - Bulgarian Academy of SciencesK Mallot - Deutsches Elektronen-SynchrotronG Maneva - Bulgarian Academy of SciencesM Manganaro - Universidad de La LagunaK Mannheim - University of WürzburgL Maraschi - National Institute for AstrophysicsB Marcote - Universitat de BarcelonaM Mariotti - University of PaduaM Martínez - IFAED Mazin - The University of TokyoU Menzel - Max Planck SocietyJ. M Miranda - University of SienaR Mirzoyan - Max Planck SocietyA Moralejo - IFAEE Moretti - Max Planck SocietyD Nakajima - The University of TokyoV Neustroev - University of TurkuA Niedzwiecki - University of ŁódźM Nievas Rosillo - Universidad Complutense de MadridK Nilsson - University of TurkuK Nishijima - The University of TokyoK Noda - Max Planck SocietyL Nogués - IFAEA Overkemping - Technische Universität Dortmund, Dortmund, GermanyS Paiano - University of PaduaJ Palacio - IFAEM Palatiello - University of UdineD Paneque - Max Planck SocietyR Paoletti - University of SienaJ. M Paredes - Universitat de BarcelonaX Paredes-Fortuny - Universitat de Barcelona, ICC, IEEC-UB, Barcelona, SpainG Pedaletti - Deutsches Elektronen-SynchrotronM Peresano - University of UdineL Perri - National Institute for AstrophysicsM Persic - University of BolognaJ Poutanen - University of TurkuP. G. Prada Moroni - University of PisaE Prandini - ETH ZurichI Puljak - University of RijekaI Reichardt - University of PaduaW Rhode - Technische Universität Dortmund, Dortmund, GermanyM Ribó - Universitat de BarcelonaJ Rico - IFAEJ. Rodriguez Garcia - Max Planck SocietyT Saito - The University of TokyoK Satalecka - Deutsches Elektronen-SynchrotronS Schröder - Technische Universität Dortmund, Dortmund, GermanyC Schultz - University of PaduaT Schweizer - Max Planck SocietyS. N Shore - University of PisaA Sillanpää - University of TurkuJ Sitarek - University of ŁódźI Snidaric - University of RijekaD Sobczynska - University of ŁódźA Stamerra - National Institute for AstrophysicsT Steinbring - University of WürzburgM Strzys - Max Planck SocietyT Surić - University of RijekaL Takalo - University of TurkuF Tavecchio - National Institute for AstrophysicsP Temnikov - Bulgarian Academy of SciencesT Terzić - University of RijekaD Tescaro - University of PaduaM Teshima - The University of TokyoJ Thaele - Technische Universität Dortmund, Dortmund, GermanyD. F Torres - ICREA and Institute for Space SciencesT Toyama - Max Planck SocietyA Treves - University of UdineG Vanzo - Universidad de La LagunaV Verguilov - Bulgarian Academy of SciencesI Vovk - Max Planck SocietyJ. E Ward - IFAEM Will - Universidad de La LagunaM. H Wu - Consejo Superior de Investigaciones CientíficasR Zanin - Universitat de BarcelonaA. U Abeysekara - University of UtahS Archambault - McGill UniversityA Archer - Washington University in St. LouisW Benbow - Harvard UniversityR Bird - University College DublinM Buchovecky - University of California, Los AngelesJ. H Buckley - Washington University in St. LouisV Bugaev - Washington University in St. LouisM. P Connolly - Ollscoil na Gaillimhe – University of GalwayW Cui - Purdue University West LafayetteH. J Dickinson - Iowa State UniversityA Falcone - Pennsylvania State UniversityQ Feng - Purdue University West LafayetteJ. P Finley - Purdue University West LafayetteH Fleischhack - Deutsches Elektronen-SynchrotronA Flinders - University of UtahL Fortson - University of MinnesotaG. H Gillanders - Ollscoil na Gaillimhe – University of GalwayS Griffin - McGill UniversityJ Grube - Adler PlanetariumM Hütten - Deutsches Elektronen-SynchrotronD Hanna - McGill UniversityJ Holder - University of DelawareT. B Humensky - Columbia UniversityP Kaaret - University of IowaP Kar - University of UtahN Kelley-Hoskins - Deutsches Elektronen-SynchrotronM Kertzman - DePauw UniversityD Kieda - University of UtahM Krause - Deutsches Elektronen-SynchrotronF Krennrich - Iowa State UniversityM. J Lang - Ollscoil na Gaillimhe – University of GalwayG Maier - Deutsches Elektronen-SynchrotronA McCann - McGill UniversityP Moriarty - Ollscoil na Gaillimhe – University of GalwayR Mukherjee - Columbia UniversityD Nieto - Columbia UniversityS O'Brien - University College DublinR. A Ong - University of California, Los AngelesN Otte - Georgia Institute of TechnologyN Park - University of ChicagoJ Perkins - Goddard Space Flight CenterA Pichel - Universidad de Buenos AiresM Pohl - University of PotsdamA Popkow - University of California, Los AngelesE Pueschel - University College DublinJ Quinn - University College DublinK Ragan - McGill UniversityP. T Reynolds - Cork Institute of TechnologyG. T Richards - Georgia Institute of TechnologyE Roache - Harvard UniversityA. C Rovero - Universidad de Buenos AiresC Rulten - University of MinnesotaI Sadeh - Deutsches Elektronen-SynchrotronM Santander - Columbia UniversityG. H Sembroski - Purdue University West LafayetteK Shahinyan - University of MinnesotaI Telezhinsky - University of PotsdamJ. V Tucci - Purdue University West LafayetteJ Tyler - McGill UniversityS. P Wakely - University of ChicagoA Weinstein - Iowa State UniversityP Wilcox - University of IowaA Wilhelm - University of PotsdamD. A Williams - University of California, Santa CruzB Zitzer - Argonne National LaboratoryS Razzaque - University of JohannesburgM Villata - Osservatorio Astrofisico di TorinoC. M Raiteri - Osservatorio Astrofisico di TorinoH. D Aller - University of MichiganM. F Aller - University of MichiganV. M Larionov - St Petersburg UniversityA. A Arkharov - Pulkovo ObservatoryD. A Blinov - University of CreteN. V Efimova - Pulkovo ObservatoryT. S Grishina - St Petersburg UniversityV. A Hagen-Thorn - Astronomical Institute, St. Petersburg State University, St. Petersburg, RussiaE. N Kopatskaya - St Petersburg UniversityL. V Larionova - St Petersburg UniversityE. G Larionova - St Petersburg UniversityD. A Morozova - St Petersburg UniversityI. S Troitsky - St Petersburg UniversityR Ligustri - Circolo Astrofili Talmassons, Campoformido, ItalyP Calcidese - Osservatorio Astrofisico della Regione Autonoma Valle d'Aosta, ItalyA Berdyugin - University of TurkuO. M Kurtanidze - Kazan Federal UniversityM. G Nikolashvili - Abastumani Observatory, Abastumani, GeorgiaG. N Kimeridze - Abastumani Observatory, Abastumani, GeorgiaL. A Sigua - Abastumani Observatory, Abastumani, GeorgiaS. O Kurtanidze - Abastumani Observatory, Abastumani, GeorgiaR. A Chigladze - Abastumani Observatory, Abastumani, GeorgiaW. P Chen - National Central UniversityE Koptelova - National Central UniversityT Sakamoto - Aoyama Gakuin UniversityA. C Sadun - University of Colorado DenverJ. W Moody - Brigham Young UniversityC Pace - Brigham Young UniversityR Pearson III - Brigham Young UniversityY Yatsu - Tokyo Institute of TechnologyY Mori - Tokyo Institute of TechnologyA Carraminyana - National Institute of Astrophysics, Optics and ElectronicsL Carrasco - National Institute of Astrophysics, Optics and ElectronicsE de la Fuente - Universidad de GuadalajaraJ. P Norris - University of DenverP. S Smith - University of ArizonaA Wehrle - Space Science InstituteM. A Gurwell - Harvard UniversityAlma Zook - Pomona CollegeC Pagani - University of LeicesterM Perri - Instituto Politécnico NacionalM Capalbi - Instituto Politécnico NacionalA Cesarini - University of TrentoH. A Krimm - Goddard Space Flight CenterY. Y Kovalev - Max Planck SocietyYu. A Kovalev - Astro Space CenterE Ros - Universitat de ValènciaA. B Pushkarev - Crimean Astrophysical ObservatoryM. L Lister - Purdue University West LafayetteK. V Sokolovsky - National Observatory of AthensM Kadler - University of WürzburgG Piner - Whittier CollegeA Lähteenmäki - Aalto UniversityM Tornikoski - Aalto UniversityE Angelakis - Max Planck SocietyT. P Krichbaum - Max Planck SocietyI Nestoras - Max Planck SocietyL Fuhrmann - Max Planck SocietyJ. A Zensus - Max Planck SocietyP Cassaro - INAFA Orlati - Istituto di Radioastronomia di BolognaG Maccaferri - Istituto di Radioastronomia di BolognaP Leto - Osservatorio Astrofisico di CataniaM Giroletti - Istituto di Radioastronomia di BolognaJ. L Richards - Purdue University West LafayetteW Max-Moerbeck - Max Planck Institute for Radio AstronomyA. C. S Readhead - California Institute of TechnologyVERITAS Collaboration
- Resource Type
- Journal article
- Publication Details
- Astronomy and astrophysics (Berlin), Vol.603, p.A31
- DOI
- 10.1051/0004-6361/201629540
- ISSN
- 0004-6361
- eISSN
- 1432-0746
- Language
- English
- Date published
- 12/30/2016
- Academic Unit
- Physics and Astronomy
- Record Identifier
- 9984199661302771
Metrics
4 Record Views