Journal article
Single-blind test of nine methane-sensing satellite systems from three continents
Atmospheric measurement techniques, Vol.17(2), pp.765-782
01/31/2024
DOI: 10.5194/amt-17-765-2024
Abstract
Satellite-based remote sensing enables detection and mitigation of large point sources of climate-warming methane. These satellites will have the greatest impact if stakeholders have a clear-eyed assessment of their capabilities. We performed a single-blind test of nine methane-sensing satellites from three continents and five countries, including both commercial and government satellites. Over 2 months, we conducted 82 controlled methane releases during satellite overpasses. Six teams analyzed the resulting data, producing 134 estimates of methane emissions. Of these, 80 (58 %) were correctly identified, with 46 true positive detections (34 %) and 34 true negative non-detections (25 %). There were 41 false negatives, in which teams missed a true emission, and 0 false positives, in which teams incorrectly claimed methane was present. All eight satellites that were given a nonzero emission detected methane at least once, including the first single-blind evaluation of the EnMAP, Gaofen 5, and Ziyuan 1 systems. In percent terms, quantification error across all satellites and teams is similar to aircraft-based methane remote sensing systems, with 55 % of mean estimates falling within +/- 50 % of the metered value. Although teams correctly detected emissions as low as 0.03 metric tons of methane per hour, it is unclear whether detection performance in this test is representative of real-world field performance. Full retrieval fields submitted by all teams suggest that in some cases it may be difficult to distinguish true emissions from background artifacts without a known source location. Cloud interference is significant and appears to vary across teams and satellites. This work confirms the basic efficacy of the tested satellite systems in detecting and quantifying methane, providing additional insight into detection limits and informing experimental design for future satellite-focused controlled methane release testing campaigns.
Details
- Title: Subtitle
- Single-blind test of nine methane-sensing satellite systems from three continents
- Creators
- Evan D. Sherwin - Lawrence Berkeley National LaboratorySahar H. El Abbadi - Lawrence Berkeley National LaboratoryPhilippine M. Burdeau - Stanford UniversityZhan Zhang - Stanford UniversityZhenlin Chen - Stanford UniversityJeffrey S. Rutherford - Stanford UniversityYuanlei Chen - Stanford UniversityAdam R. Brandt - Stanford University
- Resource Type
- Journal article
- Publication Details
- Atmospheric measurement techniques, Vol.17(2), pp.765-782
- Publisher
- Copernicus Gesellschaft Mbh
- DOI
- 10.5194/amt-17-765-2024
- ISSN
- 1867-1381
- eISSN
- 1867-8548
- Number of pages
- 18
- Grant note
- Stanford Natural Gas Initiative Environmental Defense Fund Global Methane Hub International Methane Emissions Observatory initiative of the United Nations Environment Programme
- Language
- English
- Date published
- 01/31/2024
- Academic Unit
- Civil and Environmental Engineering
- Record Identifier
- 9984843607002771
Metrics
1 Record Views